Closed ↑ $225,000 OVER ASK

133 S Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Listing Provided by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty







This beautifully handcrafted home feels like a piece of 'old Shelter Island' brought into the present. Atop a slight rise, giving the home access to the Southwest summer breezes from Peconic Bay, you are a world apart, surrounded by mature perennial plantings, an orchard, and gardens of blueberries. This 1.8 acre property allows room for a pool, home expansion, & garage, if so desired. The living room is centered around an impressive fireplace created with local stones. Utilizing the wood burning stove, the large porch overlooking the plantings becomes available for cozy year-round use. The wood floors are hand pegged, with solid wood paneling, the doors & beams are reminiscent of the loving craftsmanship that went into this home. The property has easy access to Wades Beach, South Ferry & Mashomack Preserve.

Features of 133 Midway Road

MLS# 3356490
Price $1,250,000
Sold Price $1,475,000
Total Taxes $4,200
Bedrooms 3
Bathrooms 1
Full Baths 1
Square Footage 1,510
Lot Square Footage 78,408
Acres 1.80
Year Built 1955
Type Residential
Sub-Type Single Family Residence
Style Cottage
Status Closed

Community Information

Address 133 S Midway Road
Subdivision Shorewood
City Shelter Island
County Suffolk
State NY
Zip Code 11964


Parking Private, Driveway, No Garage
View Panoramic, Other
Is Waterfront Yes
Waterfront Beach Access
Has Pool No


Interior Hardwood
Interior Features Master Downstairs, First Floor Bedroom, Living Room/Dining Room Combo
Appliances Cooktop, Oven, Refrigerator
Heating Oil, Baseboard
Cooling None
Fireplace Yes
# of Fireplaces 1
Fireplaces Wood Burning Stove
Has Basement Yes
Basement Partial, Unfinished


Exterior Features Private Entrance
Lot Description Sloped, Private
Construction Frame, Cedar, Shake Siding

School Information

District Shelter Island
Elementary Shelter Island School
Middle Shelter Island School
High Shelter Island School

Additional Information

Date Listed November 1st, 2021
Date Sold February 9th, 2022
Days on Market 13
Zoning A-residential
Short Sale No
RE / Bank Owned No

Offer is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed.

Listing Map

Request a Showing

Provide a valid email address.
When would you like to view this property?